|
AS MARKETS
tighten, it is getting more difficult for agents and
brokers to place some specialty-lines risks. As they
search for markets, however, agents have one tool
available to them that didn't exist in the last hard
market: the Internet. In the past couple of years, a
number of Web sites have been developed that help
producers find markets for specialty business and in
many cases obtain quotes. Some of these sites, including
iwix.net and Widelines.com, have fallen by the wayside.
Others are still very much in business. What follows is
a look at some of these sites, presented in alphabetical
order.
BIG
'I' MARKETS
This is a
service that the Independent Insurance Agents of America
introduced a little more than a year ago. Individual
state associations decide whether to make the program
available to their members. The Independent Insurance
Agents of New Jersey was the first to do so. Currently,
the program also is available to Big I members in Iowa,
New Hampshire, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania and
Virginia, according to Ryann Harris, IIAA director of
specialty markets. The state associations provide their
members with access to the Big "I" Markets site, Ms.
Harris said. Eligible agents also can access the site
through links on the IIAA's Web site (www.iiaa.org) or
on the Web sites of the individual
state associations.
Currently,
the site gives agents access to more than 20 types of
coverage, including such specialty products as ocean
marine insurance, miscellaneous professional liability,
public entity insurance and employment practices
liability insurance.
After
agents select a product, Ms. Harris said they can review
underwriting and coverage information, view credentials
of the company providing the product, download specimen
policies, download sales tools and educational
information applicable to the product, or simply request
a quote without doing any of the above. The system also
tells agents how they can contact the underwriter "so
they don't feel like they're simply dealing with a
computer screen," Ms. Harris said.
After an
agent fills out an application, the underwriter is
informed of the activity, can access the information in
the Big "I" Markets system and can quote or decline the
risk online. The agent and underwriter can upload and
download files to each other, Ms. Harris said, and
continue the submission process through binder
confirmation.
Agents
using Big "I" Markets do not incur access fees or have
to meet volume requirements. They receive the same
commissions they would if they were doing business with
the insurers on their own, Ms. Harris said. IIAA, she
said, is compensated for the service via royalty
arrangements with the participating insurers.
COVERAGEFIRST.COM (www.coveragefirst.com)
This Web
site is a division of Risk Placement Services, a
national wholesale broker. The site gives agents and
brokers access to some 20 specialty products, including
programs for nonprofit organizations, vacant property,
cyber liability, self-storage facilities and builders
risk insurance. At this point, many of the programs are
owned by Risk Placement Services, according to Dustin
Davis, the managing director of CoverageFirst.com. The
site also has been adding programs from various MGAs, he
said. Both admitted and nonadmitted programs are
available at the site. Most of the programs accept
online applications and provide online quotes, Davis
said.
The site
also has a feature called Coverage Pro that enables
agents to request a search for any type of coverage. One
of Risk Placement Service's seven offices will then
search the markets on behalf of the agent. "The idea was
to facilitate that first phone call, where the agent
asks, 'Say, do you have a market for this?'' Davis said.
"We'll search our database, see if we have a market for
them and respond within 24 hours."
Rather than
enter into separate brokerage agreements with the
different programs accessible through the site, agents
sign one contract with CoverageFirst.com As part of the
process, they must show evidence of $1 million in
E&O insurance and be properly licensed in the states
in which they do business. There is no registration fee,
Davis said, or volume commitment. The brokerage
agreement gives agents access to all programs currently
available at the site and any that will be added in the
future.
Agents
negotiate commissions with the individual programs.
"It's pretty much the standard commission arrangement,"
Davis said, adding that CoverageFirst takes no part of
the commission.
INSURANCENOODLE (www.insurancenoodle.com.)
This site,
which has been known primarily as a site for placing
small-business accounts, announced last month that it
intends to expand its offering to include some specialty
and niche products. Co-founder Robert Rudy said
InsuranceNoodle is staying with its core business, "but
we're expanding outside of what I would call the
plain-vanilla BOP."
Last month,
the site began offering employment practices liability
insurance in four Midwestern states on a test basis and
expects to offer EPLI nationwide within a few months.
The site also introduced an E&O/BOP product from
Chubb for emerging information technology
companies.
Rudy said
InsuranceNoodle has engaged Woolard Gioia Blundell
Associates, a consulting firm with expertise in program
business, to help it screen the marketplace for suitable
products. It also will help InsuranceNoodle develop and
obtain insurers for its own "private-label" programs,
although Rudy said those probably will take nine to 12
months to create and to clear the state regulatory
process. In the meantime, InsuranceNoodle will look for
regional specialty insurers that are
looking for wider distribution of their existing
products. Among the types of risks that Rudy said
InsuranceNoodle plans to serve are restaurants,
truckers, hotels/motels and habitational
risks.
Agents must
contract with Insur-anceNoodle to access its markets.
Until recently, agents shared their commissions 50/50
with the Web site. Rudy said agents placing business
through the site now retain 70% of the commission on
workers compensation policies having premiums greater
than $20,000 and on all other policies generating $5,000
or more in premiums.
MARKETSCOUT (www.marketscout.com)
The site
gives agents and brokers access to markets for more than
500 industry and coverage classifications, according to
founder and CEO Richard Kerr. Kerr formerly was chairman
and CEO of Lambert Fenchurch, an international broker
that acquired many retail insurance
agencies.
"Many of
the agents we met with were good folks and didn't
necessarily want to sell out, but obviously they did not
have access to the markets they needed," Kerr said, "nor
did they have the technical expertise some of the larger
companies had."
Kerr said
he left Lambert Fen-church and created MarketScout to
address those problems. For each type of product
offered, MarketScout selects what it calls a "best of
class" market. Agents interact online with each market
via an "e-industry specialist." These specialists are
MGAs, program administrators or insurance company
underwriters.
A committee
considers the qualifications of each potential "best of
class" partner. "We look at their financials, Best's
ratings, management styles, commercial practices, how
long they've been in business, what their claims-paying
history has been, who the underwriter is, what the
commissions are," Kerr said. He added that a specialist
also must have at least 10 years' experience and full
underwriting authority for the product to be offered.
Although MarketScout looks outside for most of its
products and insurance experts, it has some 25 to 30
in-house programs for which it employs its own
underwriters.
Under
Kerr's approach, a retail agent who uses the site to
seek a quote for, say, a trucker in Tulsa, Okla., will
receive just one quote, which comes from the "best of
class" insurance company for that type of risk and
territory. "We're not going to put up 15 different
companies and 'spreadsheet' them against each other,"
Kerr said, adding that market-locator sites that adopted
that strategy largely have failed because underwriters
do not want to write business in a multiple-carrier
"cheapest price wins" Internet
format.
Kerr said
his site recently registered its 10,000th retail agent.
Agents must sign a producer agreement with MarketScout,
provide evidence of E&O insurance and meet other
requirements. Agents undergo a background check that can
include an examination of their credit histories, among
other things. Kerr said that 25% to 30% of applicants
are rejected.
Agents
receive full commissions from the site's markets, Kerr
said, and have no volume requirements to
meet.
Kerr said
that MarketScout derives its income from an annual
licensing fee paid by each selected "best of class"
market. It also receives a percentage of the premium
each market receives.
In addition
to obtaining quotes for everything from explosives
manufacturers to acupuncturists, retail agents can place
standard business, including small commercial and
workers comp, through MarketScout.
PROGRAMBUSINESS.COM (www.programbusiness.com)
This Web
site is owned by National Marketing Services, a
telemarketing company for insurance agents. Larry
Neilson, CEO of both organizations, said that the idea
behind ProgramBusiness.com was to bring agents and
markets together. Over the years, he said, NMS has built
up a database of more than 20,000 retail
property-
casualty
agencies that can be searched by such criteria as
premium volume, mix of business and location. MGAs and
insurers have expressed a desire to purchase all or part
of the list. Neilson, while interested in helping these
markets, said he was reluctant to sell the list
outright. On the other hand, he said he was aware that
agents using his telemarketing services needed products
to sell and could benefit from gaining access to the
markets. "So ProgramBusiness.com kind of solves both of
those problems," he said.
MGAs,
insurers and program administrators can purchase
"storefronts" on the Web site for a flat annual fee.
Agents looking for a particular product can search those
storefronts. Neilson said that ProgramBusiness. com also
drives traffic to the storefronts via "permission-based"
marketing. He said his database contains the names and
e-mail addresses of more than 17,000 agents that have
given him permission to e-mail them a newsletter every
10 days. The newsletter contains a variety of articles
and also keeps readers apprised of new products
available from the storefront owners. Neilson said
storefront owners also are permitted to market directly
to the NMS database via e-mail or broadcast fax. For
instance, a storefront owner can send a message to all
agents in the database who reside in Oklahoma and Kansas
and who have premium volume greater than $2 million.
"The pull-through rate is somewhere between 5% and 7%
because it's a permission-based list," Neilson
said.
Retail
agents, on the other hand, can peruse the site's various
storefronts, some of which enable agents to submit
applications online and obtain quotes, or contain links
to an owner's Web site, where agents can conduct such
transactions. Agents also can use a search engine to
locate markets for a certain product in a particular
state. The search engine will list the storefront owners
first, Neilson said, but then also show any others that
ProgramBusines.com is aware of. "We list those for free
because we want (the site) to be a true exchange where
agents can see the total picture," he said, "not just
who is paying us."
Agents
wishing to use the site don't have to meet any
qualifications. Nor does the site take any part of an
agent's commission or charge any fees. "We are not an
MGA," Neilson said. "What we are is a
facilitator."
SILVER
PLUME MARKETS (www.silverplume.com)
This is a
look-up service that contains listings for more than
6,500 markets. Chris McMurray, Silver Plume's director
of marketing and strategic business development, says
the listings are updated quarterly and, in some cases,
monthly.
McMurray
said an agent can search this database by the product
that the agent desires and the state in which it is to
be sold. Agents also can search the database by the type
of business to be insured. In response, the database
provides the agent with complete contact information,
including a specific person to call or e-mail. The
results of a search also include such information as a
program's name and coverages, liability limits, minimum
premiums and commissions. After obtaining this
information, an agent contacts the market direct, rather
than through Silver Plume Markets.
Silver
Plume Markets is part of Silver Plume's traditional
CD-ROM subscriber service. That service also has been
available online for the past year, McMurray said.
Silver Plume Markets also can be obtained as part of
Silver Plume's new Sage product, which was introduced
last month. McMurray said that Sage uses proprietary
technology to give agents access to information they can
use to sell and service businesses more effectively. He
said a search for "machine shops," for instance, will
turn up such things as a coverage analysis, checklists,
recommended coverage, risk management considerations and
sample brochures. After using Sage to become
knowledgeable about a given type of business and its
needs, agents then can use Silver Plume Markets to
obtains options for placing coverage for it, McMurray
said. Sage is an online, subscription-based service. The
subscription fee varies with agency
size.
SUPERIORACCESS.COM (www.superioraccess.com)
This is the
site of Superior Access Insurance Services, an MGA that
transacts business solely via the Internet. It
represents 37 insurers offering a variety of standard
personal- and commercial-lines products, as well as
life, health and long-term care insurance. It also
offers quotes for such specialty business as contractors
insurance and commercial umbrellas. Furthermore, it has
markets in all states for workers compensation
insurance, which can be a tough risk to place right now.
Availability of some of the site's programs varies from
state to state. Some of the programs are exclusive to
SAIS
Mike Mayo,
executive vice president of SAIS, said the site's
technology instantly underwrites submitted business.
Agents answer a series of yes/no questions for the
coverage desired, immediately get a quote and can bind
the business. For a fee, SAIS also will install its
quoting technology on an agent's Web site on a
private-label basis.
To do
business with the site, agents must enter into a
brokerage agreement with SAIS. They also must be
properly licensed and provide evidence of E&O
insurance. The site displays the commissions agents
receive for business, which range from 5% on tough
workers comp risks to 12.5% for one of the site's
contractors programs and 25% for surety
bonds.
In the past
two years, Mayo said SAIS has grown to $65 million in
premium from $18 million and to 7,750 agents from
1,900.
"We are
doing what everybody is talking about and still isn't
doing," he said. "And that is, we are writing a lot of
business over the Internet at incredibly reduced
transaction expenses."
|